Picked, not tested. Everything here is something I would buy, chosen on specs, makers and reputation rather than hands-on reviews. Some links earn us a commission at no extra cost to you; it never decides what makes the list. How we pick
Buying for someone who has watched the extended editions more times than they will admit? This is the list. Every pick comes from the LOTR & Fantasy page: things I would actually want under the tree, from a $20 game to the 8,278-piece Minas Tirith.
Prices were checked on October 9, 2026. They will move before the holidays, so the store’s price wins.
Under $50
Small budget, big payoff: the two Middle-earth games, the fantasy RPGs worth the hours, and wall art for the den.
Iluvatarposterart (Etsy)
Jon Snow poster (digital download)
$7 Digital file — you print it
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
JewelsDesignerStudio (Etsy)
Raven’s Oath hand-carved drinking horn
from $17.69 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
MistyDecorations (Etsy)
Retro Fellowship illustration print
from $22.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
ByOrki (Etsy)
Vintage Gandalf tee
from $22.62 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
MirHomeArts (Etsy)
Starry Night Middle-earth canvas
from $26.40 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Bethesda
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition
$39.99 often deeply discounted on Steam
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Windlass Steelcrafts
Viking Throwing Axe (blemished grade)
$44.96 Blemished grade: cosmetic marks, full function
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate
Viking Warrior in Moonlight — metal poster
from $44.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Larian Studios
Divinity: Original Sin 2 — Definitive Edition
$44.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Snapora (Etsy)
Gandalf vs Balrog woven blanket
from $48.75 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
Iron Throne: Break the Wheel — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate
The Witcher vs the Wolf (Anato Finnstark) — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
PictureableShop (Etsy)
Witcher-themed handmade resin dice set
from $49.99 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
House Stark: Direwolf and Weirwood — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
Lannister Dark Sigil — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
Targaryen Fire & Blood — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
House Targaryen: Fire and Blood — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate (official)
The Iron Throne — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Displate · Middle-earth licensed
The Fellowship of the Ring — metal poster
from $49.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
$50 to $150
The sweet spot: illustrated editions, a prop replica with real heft, and real wool cloaks, not costume-aisle capes.
MerlinPortraits (Etsy)
Custom knight portrait from your photo
from $51.99 Etsy starting price; made to order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
TheFoundrysHearth (Etsy)
Sauron headphone stand (16 in)
from $55.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Bodleian Library
Tolkien: Maker of Middle-earth
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Star Ace Toys
Nazgûl (Deluxe Version) Vinyl Collectible
$67.99 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Saga Press · illus. Charles Vess
The Books of Earthsea: The Complete Illustrated Edition
$70.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Vanderstelt Studio
Smaug: King Under the Mountain Fine Art Print
$75 Pre-order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Vanderstelt Studio
Flame of Udûn: The Balrog Fine Art Print
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
BladesmithArts (Etsy)
Elven King long sword replica
from $81.20 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Vanderstelt Studio
Smaug the Fire-Drake: A Dire Menace! Fine Art Print
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Vanderstelt Studio
Salvation at Mt. Doom: Here at the End of All Things Fine Art Print
$85 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Sideshow
The Fellowship of the Ring Fine Art Print (Alvaro Jimenez)
$85 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
CFCanvasPrints (Etsy)
Jon Snow, Battle of the Bastards oil-style canvas
from $89.99 Etsy starting price; sizes vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
CosCraftAtelier (Etsy)
Aragorn ranger costume: cloak, tunic, pants, belt
from $96.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
The Folio Society
The Silmarillion, illustrated by Francis Mosley
$100.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
BestCanvasDecor (Etsy)
Ring Quest movie-scene canvas print set
from $102.96 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
MatrixCosplay (Etsy)
Gandalf the Grey wizard costume: robe, hat, belt and bag
from $103.20 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
CosplayshopByAteeb (Etsy)
Geralt of Rivia cosplay outfit
from $105 Etsy starting price; sizes vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
TheDecorCrest (Etsy)
Handcrafted wooden Viking shield
from $107.58 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Weta Workshop
Phial of Galadriel 1:1 Prop Replica
$119.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
MidnightTailorStudio (Etsy)
Viking fur-trimmed leather coat
from $120.99 Etsy starting price; sizes vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Burgschneider
Hibernus Wool Hooded Cloak (brown)
$135.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
$150 to $300
Gifts that become heirlooms: the hobbit blades, slipcased books and a LEGO build for the whole family.
ArmadaCraft (Etsy)
High Elven sword, 5160 high-carbon steel
from $150.12 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
SagaSmithStudio (Etsy)
Handmade Viking axe and wolf shield set
from $157.50 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Vanderstelt Studio
Rivendell: The Last Homely House East of the Sea Art Print
$165 Pre-order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
MorgothLab (Etsy)
Bear School leather armor pieces
from $175.87 Etsy starting price; limited availability
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
United Cutlery
Sting, Sword of Frodo Baggins (UC1264)
$179.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
MorgothLab (Etsy)
Aragorn Return of the King armor pieces
from $187.67 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Star Ace Toys
Aragorn 2.0 King (Deluxe Version) Collectible Figure
$190 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Asmus Collectible Toys
Elven Warrior Sixth Scale Figure
$190 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
HarperCollins
The Hobbit Deluxe (slipcased hardcover)
$195.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Tor · Brandon Sanderson
The Stormlight Archive Hardcover Boxed Set, Books 1–5
$199.95 pre-order, releases Oct 27
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Valyrian Steel
Longclaw, the Sword of Jon Snow
from $202.90 Two editions; price varies
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Iron Studios
Lurtz, Uruk-hai Leader 1:10 Art Scale Statue
$205 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
IbraForge (Etsy)
Frodo Baggins hobbit costume
from $206.25 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Asmus Collectible Toys
Boromir Sixth Scale Figure
$213 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
BooksnMoreStore (Etsy)
The Lord of the Rings + The Hobbit, 4-volume set with custom dust jackets
from $225.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
AyakaBladeStudio (Etsy)
Handcrafted Middle-earth dwarven blade
from $231.40 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
HeavyArtDesignShop (Etsy)
Hand-forged steel “reforged king’s sword” replica
from $240.65 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
The Folio Society
The Lord of the Rings, 3 volumes in slipcase
$260.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Asmus Collectible Toys
Faramir Sixth Scale Figure
$265 Pre-order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
OutcastProps (Etsy)
White Tree leather ranger bracers
from $269.77 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
United Cutlery
Orcrist, Sword of Thorin Oakenshield
$279.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
United Cutlery
Glamdring, Sword of Gandalf (UC1265)
$279.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
The splurge: $300 and up
For the superfan who already has everything: sixth-scale statues, the sword reforged, and the 8,278-piece White City.
Iron Studios
Sauron Unleashed 1:10 Scale Statue
$305 Pre-order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
TheHavenArmory (Etsy)
Jaime Lannister-inspired steel armor set
from $314.10 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
FrevenJackets (Etsy)
Aragorn ranger leather coat, vest and wool cloak
from $315.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Iron Studios
Aragorn Unleashed 1:10 Art Scale Statue
$335 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
SwordBuyShop (Etsy)
Handmade Sword of Geralt
from $349 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
JacketLane (Etsy)
Corlys Velaryon-inspired wool coat
from $370.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Asmus Collectible Toys
Gandalf the White Sixth Scale Figure
$385 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Asmus Collectible Toys
Saruman Crown Series Sixth Scale Figure
$395 Pre-order
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Weta Workshop
Aragorn, Hunter of the Plains (1:6)
$399.00
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Jens Hansen
The One Ring, Sterling Silver with Elvish Runes
$399.00 made to order, check your size
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
ClothAuraCo (Etsy)
Ranger hooded cloak and tunic costume
from $400.00 Etsy starting price; options vary
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
OutcastProps (Etsy)
Viking leather pauldron and harness
from $410.37 Etsy starting price
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
United Cutlery
Andúril, Sword of King Elessar — Museum Collection (UC3516)
$599.99
Price checked Oct 9, 2026
Iron Studios
Cave Troll Deluxe 1:10 Scale Statue
$730 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Prime 1 Studio
Jon Snow Statue (Prime 1 x Blitzway)
$1,110 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
ElMarquesLARP (Etsy)
Black leather Viking armor, full set
from $1,289.72 Etsy starting price; made to measure
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Prime 1 Studio
Witch-king of Angmar (Ultimate Version) Quarter Scale Statue
$1,545 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Infinity Studio x Penguin Toys
Legolas (Premium Edition) Statue
$1,749 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Prime 1 Studio
The Dark Lord Sauron 1:3 Scale Statue
$1,905 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Prime 1 Studio
Gandalf the Grey (Ultimate Version) 1:4 Scale Statue
$1,970 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Infinity Studio x Penguin Toys
Gimli Statue
$3,234 Sold out
Price checked Oct 15, 2026
Read next
Keep exploring
The Geek Drop
One email a week: three new finds, one thing worth the money, no spam.